homepage
rss
site map
about
events
links
choose language
Intercultural
Lexicon

Cosmopolitism

It is the philosophical and political concept that extends the ideas of citizenship and homeland to the whole world and to all humankind, opposing the particularity of nations and national states.

Read more

Revolution

Though its semantic origins are pre-modern, revolution has been a fundamental category of the interpretation of modern times.

Read more

Nationalism

The 20th Century was par excellence the century of nationalisms. It is sufficient to remember that the causes of the two world wars were directly linked to the consequences of nationalist doctrine exalting all that belongs to one’s own nation..

Read more

Terrorism

This is an ambiguous word.

Read more

Relativism

Few concepts are both so controversial and recurrent within the philosophical and cultural debate as the concept of relativism.

Read more
Reset
A month of ideas.
Giancarlo Bosetti Editor-in-chief
Association for dialogue and intercultural understanding
Essays
Friday, 16 June 2017

Russia: Where Homosexuality is Still a Disease

Giovanna De Maio

‘Honor killing’, ubijstva chesti in Russian, is fairly common in Chechnya where homosexuals are often killed by relatives in order to preserve the family’s honor from the shame they have brought. Recently, the news of a gay concentration camp in Chechnya has caused a commotion. According to the Russian newspaper Novaya Gazeta, around 100 people have been locked up there because of their sexual orientation


Humanitarian organizations, primarily LGBT Network, who have offered shelter to the victims in order to help mediate their release, have denounced the violence which the inmates have had to suffer, ranging from being beaten with rubber tubes to electrocutions.

Regardless of the significance of the events, Russian society has remained silent in their regards. According to the polls, most Russians still consider homosexuality as a disease. A return to traditional, orthodox values is being used as a political tool, aimed at reaching specific goals both at home and abroad which may explain the silence of the authorities in regards to this case.

The legal framework

The Russian federal law “for the Purpose of Protecting Children from Information Advocating for a Denial of Traditional Family Values”, also known as the gay propaganda law, was approved by the State Duma on June 11th, 2013.

Its vague formulation leaves room for different interpretations and, therefore, applications. The law punishes with severe fines or with the expulsion from the country – in case the crime is committed by a foreigner – those who propagandize “non-traditional sexual relationships”. The Venice Commission of the Council of Europe, together with NGOs like Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch, condemned the text as highly discriminatory and expressed concern about the possibility that this law could represent a base to justify homophobic violence.

The social framework

Since 2006, gay pride parades are no longer authorized in Russia. The recent episodes of violence in Chechnya did not receive much attention in Moscow. The only newspaper that briefly spoke of this issue was the Novaya Gazeta, which has also been sued for defamation by the Chechen authorities.

Russian public opinion has not shown much affection for this cause. Rather, Levada Center polls suggest an interesting change of opinion on this topic from 2013 to 2015, before and after the Ukrainian crisis. The most notable data is that which concerns the negative attitude towards homosexuals: the number of those in favour of homosexual freedoms decreased from 31% to 25%; the number of those who are personally uncomfortable when interacting with homosexuals has risen from 16% to 22%.

Most importantly, the poll assessed that 37% of respondents maintain that homosexuality is a disease to be treated medicinally.

Perhaps this data would not be too dissimilar in ‘advanced’ countries where such judgements are considered unacceptable. These countries, however, simply do not have restrictions towards homosexuals similar to those of Russia.

Morality as a political tool

In such a strongly traditional society as the Chechen one, it is simply unacceptable to be homosexual. However, there are some elements suggesting that it is not entirely a persecution from a moral standpoint. The Novaya Gazeta reports that some of those arrested were affiliated to the head of religious affairs in Chechnya along with two famous TV hosts; leading to the suspicion of this being a fairly efficient way to eliminate opponents of Ramzan Kadyrov’s regime.

It is however worth reflecting on another point which goes beyond the Chechen episode. Following the Ukrainian crisis, the Kremlin began to insist, in a particularly insistent manner, on Russian cultural exceptionalism and its civilizing mission through the gradual establishment of certain personalities of a strongly nationalist tendency as opinion leaders.

From this perspective Russian values, mixed with Slavic and orthodox tradition, become “incompatible with the western liberal path, just as much as with communism”, as the Russian Cultural Minister declared in 2014. In this light, it is also possible to understand Russia’s convergence with Eurosceptic parties that espouse conservative values and oppose LGBT rights and immigration.

The political objective beneath this call to traditional values is to thus reinforce the Russian identity sentiment and consolidate consensus for the regime and its political choices, that often times are heavy to bear, not only for the economy but in terms of human losses. At the same time, these beliefs reiterate Russia’s frustration with not being considered a leader in the international arena, resulting in an assertive opposition to the West and its values, an obvious example of which would be its acceptance of sexual liberties.

Newsletter

Sign up to receive our newsletter


Questo sito utilizza i cookies per offrirti una migliore esperienza di navigazione, in particolare vengono utilizzati cookies tecnici per consentire la normale navigazione e fruizione del sito stesso e dei suoi servizi; cookies di terze parti per raccogliere informazioni, in forma aggregata, sul numero degli utenti del nostro sito e su come questi visitano lo stesso e cookie di profilazione al fine di inviare messaggi pubblicitari in linea con le preferenze manifestate dall'utente nell'ambito della navigazione in rete.

Se vuoi saperne di più o negare il consenso a tutti o solo ad alcuni cookies clicca qui.
Se nascondi questo banner o accedi a un qualunque elemento della pagina acconsenti all'uso dei cookies.