homepage
rss
site map
about
events
links
choose language
Intercultural
Lexicon

Ethnic Violence

Many of the conflicts or mass violence of recent decades have been characterised by the adjective “ethnic”. This means that the leading players were groups opposing one another on the basis of identitarian, religious, linguistic or more generally cultural assertions..

Read more

Dialogue

In recent times, "dialogue" has emerged as an important and even central notion in both philosophy and politics.

Read more

Modernity

The concept of modernity can be analysed from various points of view. A sociological perspective sees modernity as the historical era arising from feudal society’s profound transformation processes and that, starting with the Protestant Reformation, sees the emergence of the new bourgeoisie..

Read more

Constitution

Constitution is a key category, one of the most important, of modern political and legal theory.

Read more

Ethno-psychiatry-Ethno-psychology

Ethno-psychiatry and ethno-psychology experiment the paths to be followed so as to address the cultural differences within the disciplinary wisdom and practices (western) of psychiatry and psychology.

Read more
Reset
A month of ideas.
Giancarlo Bosetti Editor-in-chief
Association for dialogue and intercultural understanding
Intercultural Lexicon
IT Tuesday, 7 November 2006

Culture-Civilisation

Alessandro Ferrara

The concept of culture has changed in the course of time. In the Greek world there was the concept of paideia, used to indicate the process involving the formation of the human personality achieved through learning. This use of the idea of culture survives in the link the Latin world established between culture and colere. In this sense the concept of culture continued to exist also during the Middle Ages and in early modern times, until the 18th century.


In Germanic speaking Europe it was to a certain extent the word Bildung that filled this semantic space – and for Hegel too Bildung meant the cultivating of one’s own personality through exposure to the best written and spoken elements in the world. A change of emphasises however came about in the mid 18th Century. The concept of culture started to assume a new meaning, that of a “universal heritage of knowledge and values formed in the course of humankind’s history”.  Simultaneously the concept of civility or civilisation began to emerge. Being “civilised”, unlike being “learned”, meant having experienced a process of “cultural refinement of customs” – the object of study in the work of Norbert Elias – to the extent that the main counter position then becomes that between “civilised human beings” and the “uncivilised” or “savages”.

This opposition was to bring about important developments with regards to the concept of culture. During the 18th Century literature appeared developing a comparison between the customs deeply-rooted in European western culture and those outside Europe. The 18th Century’s ethnographic memoir writing however immediately experienced the effect of undermining at its foundations the idea of a universal human nature, contributing instead to strengthening the idea that education and local forms of life within which interactions between human beings take place, has a constitutive value for culture. Many aspects considered “natural” in human beings were now ascribed to educational processes of a cultural kind – Rousseau is the most example of this. But other names instantly come to mind such as Vico, a later on at the end of the 19th Century also Dilthey. This historical change of the concept of culture was to contribute to a reformulation of relations between the concept of culture and that of civilisation, in turn leading to unfortunate consequences.

“Culture” (Kultur) and “civilisation” (Zivilisation) were to become sort of ideal-types on the basis of which modernising historical processes were interpreted. In the German debate, at the end of the 19th and the beginning of the 20th Century the dual concept of Gemeinschaft and Gesellschaft coined by Toennies would become the key for understanding the resonance that emanate from the words Kultur and Zivilisation. While the community is to be considered a “living organism”, society should according to Tönnies be seen as an “aggregate and mechanical product” (Tönnies 1963: 47). Hence the idea that community and communitarian relations presuppose cultural homogeneity, and therefore that the expression “pluralist community” is a contradiction. This is what was now added to the idea of Kultur in addition to the main meaning of “high culture”.
The word Zivilisation instead refers to an intrinsically open and pluralist culture. It becomes possible to state that the triumph of “civilization” marks the simultaneous “decline of culture”. In Spengler, the author of The Decline of the West, Kultur (understood here as a the overall cultural of an entire civilisation) is identified with the moment of the ascent and flourishing of a form of life, while Zivilisation is, once again in a negative sense, typical of the declining stages of a given form of life or a historical era. Something of this interpretation of cultural modernisation still survives: if the contraposition between “apocalyptic” and “integrated” means something to you, that something is very similar to the contraposition of once upon a time, with the apocalyptics defending Kultur and the integrated as the defenders of that surrogate “civilisation that is the oxymoronic “mass” or “popular culture”.

Newsletter

Sign up to receive our newsletter


Questo sito utilizza i cookies per offrirti una migliore esperienza di navigazione, in particolare vengono utilizzati cookies tecnici per consentire la normale navigazione e fruizione del sito stesso e dei suoi servizi; cookies di terze parti per raccogliere informazioni, in forma aggregata, sul numero degli utenti del nostro sito e su come questi visitano lo stesso e cookie di profilazione al fine di inviare messaggi pubblicitari in linea con le preferenze manifestate dall'utente nell'ambito della navigazione in rete.

Se vuoi saperne di più o negare il consenso a tutti o solo ad alcuni cookies clicca qui.
Se nascondi questo banner o accedi a un qualunque elemento della pagina acconsenti all'uso dei cookies.